More thunder, no lightning

The UN General Assembly today passed a resolution supporting the Arab League plan for Syria, which would have Bashar al Assad step aside from his presidency and turn over power to his vice president, who would form a broad coalition government and initiate a democratic transition.  The vote was 137 to 12, which is pretty lopsided even in the UNGA, where lopsided votes are common.

The opponents were:  Belarus, Bolivia, China, Cuba, DPRK, Ecuador, Iran, Nicaragua, Russia, Syria, Venezuela, Zimbabwe.  This is a crew that needs a name:  something like the antidemocrats, but snappier.

So what practical effect will this have?  Hard to say, but the legal effect is nil.  UNGA resolutions are like preseason football:  the games may be well played and show off talent, but they have no direct impact on the standings.  Only UN Security Council resolutions have legal effect.

But legal effect isn’t everything and doesn’t guarantee implementation either.  The important thing is that the “international community” has made an appropriate noise in response to Bashar al Assad’s military assault on Syria’s citizens.  This will weaken Bashar’s position both internationally and within Syria and give inspiration to his opponents, who will also bemoan international community ineffectiveness.

The real question is what should be done now.  Some will want to resort to military intervention or arming the Syrian Free Army.  This is a serious error in my book.  The worst outcome for the U.S. is a prolonged civil war in Syria, which could have a destabilizing impact on Lebanon, Iraq, Turkey and more widely.  “Safe areas” and “humanitarian corridors” would, in the absence of Syrian government cooperation, require major military intervention.

As Mona Yacoubian, Randa Slim and Aram Nerguizian were at pains to make clear this morning at a Stimson/Middle East Institute Event, there are diplomatic and political courses of action that still need to be played out:

  • The U.S. should lead on getting a “Friends of Syria” group up and running;
  • The Arab League and Turkey should lead on pressing the Syrian opposition to unify;
  • Sanctions implementation needs to be tightened, especially by the Arab League;
  • The U.S. and Turkey need to court Russian support, on grounds that their interests require a good relationship with whatever comes after Bashar;
  • The Syrian opposition has to work on peeling away Sunni and Christian merchant, as well as military, support for the regime.

As Randa Slim noted, what helps the regime is fear of instability on the one hand and Islamism on the other.  These fears would get worse with military intervention, not better.  We need more thunder, no lightning.

PS:  Somehow this “Dancing and chanting around an independence flag in Qudaysa, Damascus” tweeted by @LeShaque and retweeted by Robert Mackey grabs me this morning. It is a lot more expressive than the important, if dull, session of the UNGA yesterday and reminds us of what the resolution is really about:

Daniel Serwer

Share
Published by
Daniel Serwer

Recent Posts

Trump thumped: what does that portend for foreign policy?

The Democratic win yesterday was real and consequential. But it is not permanent or absolute.…

2 weeks ago

Winners can lose and losers can win

It might be nice if elections were translated directly into results that people voted for.…

3 weeks ago

Israel: too soon to say who really won

Netanyahu lost support but will stay in power for months more unless Eisenkot quickly forms…

3 weeks ago

One would-be autocrat down, two to go

The blatant lying, grotesque racism, corrupt money-grubbing, insulting language, and ripping off poor people is…

3 weeks ago

Three elections, one profound choice

In Serbia, Israel, and the US, corrupt ethnonationalist incumbents are trying to stem a tide…

4 weeks ago

Ukraine: the frontline and the future

This promises to be a great event!

1 month ago