Categories: Daniel Serwer

Why war

My review of Michael C. Horowitz, Allan C. Stam and Cali M. Ellis, Why Leaders Fight (Cambridge University Press, 2015) went up on War on the Rocks under the title He Who Lets Slip the Dogs of War today. Here is are the teaser first two paragraphs:

This is a book that should have been unnecessary. Its main argument is that leaders, particularly chiefs of state and government, are important to the decision to go to war. As the authors argue repeatedly, we all know this. Hitler made a difference to history that some other leader of Germany might not have. People matter. Human agency should not be ignored. Why do we have to prove it?

The problem is an academic one. American political science, in particular its international relations theory, pays little attention to the differences leaders make. Academia attributes war to institutional, structural, and internal factors, leaving little intellectual headroom for the voluminous biographies that sell so well in the mass market and fascinate war and peace practitioners like me.

The solution the authors propose to this disconnect is…[click here for the rest]

Daniel Serwer

Share
Published by
Daniel Serwer

Recent Posts

It’s not just the verdict that is unjust

This is one more lesson in why you shouldn't be too friendly to Washington and…

2 weeks ago

Kosovo should get on with governing

I hope the votes can somehow be found to make Sejdiu president, not because of…

2 weeks ago

Rehabilitation of Mladic is rehabilitation of Vucic

Miloš Ćirić, a political scientist in Belgrade, writes in Danas, Sept. 12-13, 2026: Serbia buried…

2 weeks ago

The bright spot is visible but not certain

So what's the bright spot? I hope the election. Americans on November 3 have an…

2 weeks ago

The Death of a Convicted War Criminal, Survival of an Ideology

A war criminal can die, while the ideology that made him a hero survives. That…

3 weeks ago

Montenegro, a War Criminal, and European Integration

We are witnessing a new variation on Milan Kundera’s famous *The Joke*: “Optimism is opium…

3 weeks ago