Netanyahu channels Jefferson

Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu spoke last night at AIPAC. The speech was notable for three things:

  • No vision of what peace with the Palestinians would look like–he promised that for today in Congress.
  • His assertion that “Israel is America’s indispensable ally.” I thought it was the other way around.
  • His welcoming of the Arab Spring, and his related claim that Arabs have equal rights in Israel.

On this last point, I’m glad Netanyahu took the line he did on the Arab Spring, but I’m afraid he was as insincere as the slave holder Thomas Jefferson, whose memorial he visited.  Rather than debate complex issues, I’ll quote the State Department’s last human rights report:

Principal human rights problems were institutional, legal, and societal discrimination against Arab citizens…

In Israel proper, see the New Israel Fund. For the occupied territories, pay a visit to B’tselem. Prepare to not like what you read.

The question of whether Israel is indispensable to the U.S. or the U.S. is indispensable to Israel is an important one.  The fact is that the U.S. is indispensable to Israel.  The United States would survive without the Jewish state, but Israel would not survive without American support.

Like most Americans, I am glad for that support, which helps to ensure Israeli security.  But when an Israeli prime minister gets the basic relationship backwards I’ve got to wonder what we are doing wrong.

The answer is too much support and not enough questioning.  President Obama did well last week to make clearer what everyone (including Israeli prime ministers before Netanyahu) has always assumed:  that a peace settlement would include 1967 borders with land swaps.  Putting Netanyahu on the spot was far better than conspiring with him, as Aaron David Miller would have preferred.

I’ll be listening today for what Netanyahu has to say about his vision for a peace settlement between Israel and Palestine.  I hope it proves better than what I expect.

Daniel Serwer

Share
Published by
Daniel Serwer

Recent Posts

Trump thumped: what does that portend for foreign policy?

The Democratic win yesterday was real and consequential. But it is not permanent or absolute.…

2 weeks ago

Winners can lose and losers can win

It might be nice if elections were translated directly into results that people voted for.…

3 weeks ago

Israel: too soon to say who really won

Netanyahu lost support but will stay in power for months more unless Eisenkot quickly forms…

3 weeks ago

One would-be autocrat down, two to go

The blatant lying, grotesque racism, corrupt money-grubbing, insulting language, and ripping off poor people is…

3 weeks ago

Three elections, one profound choice

In Serbia, Israel, and the US, corrupt ethnonationalist incumbents are trying to stem a tide…

4 weeks ago

Ukraine: the frontline and the future

This promises to be a great event!

1 month ago