Categories: Daniel Serwer

Russian “immunity”

Milana Pejic of the Belgrade daily Blic asked me yesterday about immunity for Russian troops stationed in Serbia, which President Putin has reportedly requested. I responded:

I’m not sure what “immunity” means. As the state sending soldiers, sailors or airmen to deploy in a foreign country, the US always requires that it retain jurisdiction over them.  If they commit a crime, they get tried in the US, not in the state in which they are deployed, unless the US waives its right to exercise jurisdiction (which it occasionally does). There is no “immunity” in the sense of protection from prosecution. This is all regulated in what is called a “status of forces agreement.” I really don’t know what the Russians do, though I wouldn’t be entirely surprised if they insist on something closer to immunity.

Quite apart from the question of criminal jurisdiction, I can’t think of any EU countries that host Russian bases on their territory. Are there any?* If Serbia is serious about EU membership, I wonder if it wants to continue to host the Russians at all. If not, there would be no point in providing immunity (or even sending state jurisdiction). An easy way out might be to refuse the Russian request.

I see Prime Minister Vucic is talking in the press about the importance of NATO to the protection of Serbs in northern Kosovo. Belgrade needs to weigh carefully whether its present policy of hedging between NATO/EU and Russia is really in the Serbian interest.

Some day fairly soon all Serbia’s neighbors will be NATO members. What sense would it make then for Serbia to host a Russian base? What impact will that have on relations with the neighbors? Moscow may call it a humanitarian center, but we know from the recent intentional Russian bombing of hospitals in Syria how serious Moscow is about humanitarian issues.

*PS: the answer to this question is no.

Daniel Serwer

Share
Published by
Daniel Serwer

Recent Posts

The long, difficult road ahead

The Israelis are the victors for now. With authority comes responsibility. They need to make…

1 day ago

How do we get out of here?

Only people can force the P5 leaders to undertake the way out of the catastrophic…

1 week ago

Round peg won’t fit square hole

A lot of people could get killed in a peace operation of this difficulty. The…

2 weeks ago

We are going to unknown places

Trump's America is a place where freedom of speech is in doubt, right-wing violence is…

2 weeks ago

Will Hamas surrender, fight, or evaporate?

The Trump Administration's 20-point peace plan for Gaza calls for the unconditional surrender, disarmament and…

2 weeks ago

How experts prevail

They can and sometimes do, provided they organize well and rely on expertise to develop…

2 months ago