Categories: Daniel Serwer

Two issues portend

Yesterday, I welcomed the UAE/Israel normalization of relations. I have no regrets about that.

But, as in all announcements of agreements still to be formally drafted and signed, there are question marks:

  • Where will the UAE Embassy be located?
  • Will Israel’s territory be defined, either explicitly or implicitly, in the formal agreements?

Israel says Jerusalem is its capital, and the Trump Administration moved the US Embassy there from Tel Aviv. If the UAE follows suit, that would be bigger news than the normalization of relations. I doubt Abu Dhabi will do that, but Israel will likely insist. How will that circle be squared?

The official statement says Israel is suspending its annexation plans, not ending them. This implies that it can in the future again threaten annexation and even do it, or back off again in exchange for another Arab country normalizing relations.

I would expect the UAE to try to avoid that by incorporating somewhere in the many agreements to be signed implicit or explicit reference to Israel’s 1967 borders, which have been the widely accepted basis for negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians. That way the UAE could claim that it has not departed in principle from support for the Palestinians and the Arab Peace Initiative, which foresaw normalizing relations with Israel once the territorial issue with Palestine was resolved.

These are two of the final status issues that have to be solved before the Israel/Palestine conflict can be considered settled: the status of Jerusalem and the extent of Israel’s sovereign territory. They are among the issues that have stymied peace efforts in the past. It will be difficult to avoid them entirely in establishing normal relations between the UAE and Israel. How they are resolved could have a big impact on prospects for peace in the future.

Daniel Serwer

Share
Published by
Daniel Serwer

Recent Posts

Violence in this good cause is not good

The demonstrators in LA need to cool it. Not because they are wrong, but because…

3 days ago

Even with a ceasefire, the war will continue

The Ukrainians expect any non-democratic regime in Moscow to continue Putin's effort. The war will…

1 week ago

Calms before the Balkan storms

Democracy and rule of law in both Bosnia and Serbia are in the balance. The…

2 weeks ago

Israel in Gaza: illegal, immoral, unwise

Israel is making two states living securely side-by-side much more difficult. Law, morality, and wisdom…

2 weeks ago

Nuclear Iran – facts, goals and opportunity 

President Trump’s decision to kill the Iran nuclear deal was an obvious failure. Lack of…

3 weeks ago

Winning the war with equanimity

As I prepare to leave Kyiv Wednesday, here are notes on issues not covered in…

1 month ago