Categories: Daniel Serwer

Too many good reasons to impeach, but he won’t

This is one of the last cyberspaces on earth where you would expect to find a video of Kevin McCarthy, California Republican and Minority Leader in the House. But here is his speech on impeachment today:

All the reasons to impeach, with a recommendation not to

McCarthy is clear that the attack on the Capitol was undemocratic, violent, and criminal, aimed at interrupting the constitutionally required certification of Electoral College votes. He states there is no evidence of left-wing Antifa involvement. He says the President bears responsibility for the attack on the Capitol, and criticizes his failure to try to stop it. He says Joe Biden won the election and will be sworn in as President next week. To all of that I say: yes.

His main complaint is that no investigation has been conducted nor hearings held, though the facts adduced in the article of impeachment are all well-known and public. He claims a vote to impeach would further divide the nation, even though he knows that half dozen, or maybe more, Republicans will vote in favor of impeachment, as will the entire majority caucus. Instead of impeachment, he prefers a fact-finding commission and a censure resolution, neither of which he can convince Democrats to vote for.

The weight of the arguments in the two previous paragraphs weighs in favor of impeachment. McCarthy nevertheless is leading the House Republican charge against it, including false allegations from members of his own caucus that Biden did not win and that the Democrats advocated violence during the Black Lives Matter demonstrations.

In conclusion, McCarthy calls for an end to polarization, making reference to the fraught transition from John Adams to Thomas Jefferson in 1801. But he ignores the fact that Adams conceded, which Trump has not. He also ignores the fact that President-elect Biden has, like Jefferson, asked his supporters to put aside division and preached forgiveness. Trump has ignored that appeal.

McCarthy wants unity. I know where he can find it: in a vote, based on the arguments he presents, in favor of impeachment.

Daniel Serwer

Share
Published by
Daniel Serwer

Recent Posts

Trump thumped: what does that portend for foreign policy?

The Democratic win yesterday was real and consequential. But it is not permanent or absolute.…

2 weeks ago

Winners can lose and losers can win

It might be nice if elections were translated directly into results that people voted for.…

3 weeks ago

Israel: too soon to say who really won

Netanyahu lost support but will stay in power for months more unless Eisenkot quickly forms…

3 weeks ago

One would-be autocrat down, two to go

The blatant lying, grotesque racism, corrupt money-grubbing, insulting language, and ripping off poor people is…

3 weeks ago

Three elections, one profound choice

In Serbia, Israel, and the US, corrupt ethnonationalist incumbents are trying to stem a tide…

4 weeks ago

Ukraine: the frontline and the future

This promises to be a great event!

1 month ago